3.9
Viewer Rating
Combines user and critic ratings from four sources
A Dream of Red Mansions (1989)
Bias Rating
Analyzing...
Leans Progressive
Viewer Rating
Rating: 3.9
Overview
A Chinese serial feature film, released in 6 parts (8 episodes) between 1988 and 1989. The film adapts the major events and incidents of the novel of the same name, depicting the fate of Jia family.
Starring Cast
Bias Dimensions
Political: Center
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Buddhism: Positive
Overview
A Chinese serial feature film, released in 6 parts (8 episodes) between 1988 and 1989. The film adapts the major events and incidents of the novel of the same name, depicting the fate of Jia family.
Starring Cast
Detailed Bias Analysis
Analyzing...
Leans Progressive
Primary
The film, based on a classic Chinese novel, primarily explores themes of love, loss, and the decline of an aristocratic family, offering a nuanced historical and cultural critique rather than promoting a specific modern political ideology. Its ultimate resolution is spiritual and philosophical, not political.
This adaptation of a classic Chinese novel features an ethnically authentic cast, which does not engage with the concept of traditional Western roles or their recasting. The narrative, while exploring complex societal structures and the roles of women within a patriarchal system, offers a nuanced critique inherent to its source material rather than an explicit, modern DEI-driven agenda.
Secondary
The film "Hong lou meng" faithfully adapts the classic novel, presenting several characters, notably the protagonist Jia Baoyu, in tender and significant same-sex relationships. These bonds are depicted with dignity and empathy, contributing to the characters' complexity without being a source of mockery or moral condemnation. The narrative affirms the worth of these affections within its broader tragic scope.
The film deeply integrates Buddhist philosophy, particularly themes of impermanence and detachment, as a profound framework for understanding the characters' struggles and the tragic nature of worldly attachments. It portrays Buddhism with respect and depth, not as a source of oppression but as a path to spiritual insight.
The film 'A Dream of Red Mansions' (1989), based on the classic Chinese novel, does not depict any identifiable transsexual characters or explore themes related to transsexual identity. Consequently, an evaluation of its portrayal of such elements is not applicable.
The movie does not contain any action or adventure elements.
The film adapts a classical novel where characters' genders are well-established. While a female actress portrays the male lead Jia Baoyu, the character is consistently presented as male within the film's narrative, aligning with the source material. No canonical characters are portrayed on screen as a different gender.
The 1988 film "Hong lou meng" is a Chinese adaptation of a classic Chinese novel. All characters, canonically Chinese, are portrayed by East Asian actors, consistent with the source material and historical context. No race swaps are present.
Viewer Rating Breakdown
User Ratings
7.7
N/A
Critic Ratings
N/A
N/A
More Like This
Leans Progressive
6.8
The Xi'an Incident
(1981)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Leans Progressive
6.9
Cliff Walkers
(2021)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Leans Progressive
7.8
Ip Man 2
(2010)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Leans Progressive
7.9
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood
(2019)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
Progressive
7.2
Ip Man 4: The Finale
(2019)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
6.8
My Love
(2021)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
Progressive
8.2
Ju Dou
(1990)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
Center
7.2
Detective Dee and the Mystery of the Phantom Flame
(2010)
Political: Center
Diversity: Moderate
Female Combat: Yes
Leans Progressive
8.4
Better Days
(2019)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Center
7.7
We Girls
(2025)
Political: Leans Right
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
8.1
Blind Shaft
(2003)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
Progressive
7.5
Big World
(2024)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
6.9
All These Years
(2023)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
7.2
The Stage
(2025)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
Center
7.5
A Writer's Odyssey
(2021)
Political: Center
Diversity: Moderate
Female Combat: Yes
Progressive
7.1
Only the River Flows
(2023)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
LGBTQ: Neutral
Leans Progressive
6.6
Tiger Wolf Rabbit
(2024)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Progressive
8.4
Farewell My Concubine
(1993)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
6.8
Curse of the Golden Flower
(2006)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
7.4
The Message
(2009)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate