7.9
Viewer Rating
Combines user and critic ratings from four sources
Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl (1919)
Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl (1919)
Overview
The love story of an abused English girl and a Chinese Buddhist in a time when London was a brutal and harsh place to live.
Starring Cast
Where to watch
Rating & Dimensions
Bias Rating
Analyzing...
Leans Progressive
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Race Swap: Yes
Buddhism: Positive
Christianity: Negative
Viewer Rating
7.9
Overview
The love story of an abused English girl and a Chinese Buddhist in a time when London was a brutal and harsh place to live.
Starring Cast
Where to watch
Detailed Bias Analysis
Analyzing...
Leans Progressive
Primary
The film is rated Left-Leaning due to its central critique of racial prejudice and domestic abuse, and its profound sympathy for marginalized characters. However, its tragic and individualistic resolution, rather than advocating for systemic change, places it at -1.
The movie features a predominantly white cast, with a white actor portraying a central Asian character. However, its narrative explicitly critiques a traditional white male identity by portraying him as a central antagonist, contrasting him with a sympathetically depicted non-white character.
Secondary
The character Cheng Huan, canonically established as Chinese, is portrayed by Richard Barthelmess, a white actor, in yellowface. This constitutes a race swap.
Buddhism is portrayed positively through Cheng Huan, who embodies its ideals of peace, compassion, and non-violence. His character stands as a moral beacon against the brutality and prejudice of the Western world, aligning the narrative with the virtues of the faith.
The film portrays the Western society, implicitly Christian, as harsh, violent, and hypocritical through characters like Battling Burrows and the general squalor. There is no significant counterbalancing positive portrayal of Christian faith or its adherents, especially when contrasted with the gentle Buddhist protagonist.
Broken Blossoms (1919) does not feature any identifiable LGBTQ+ characters or themes. The narrative centers on a heterosexual relationship and explores issues of racial prejudice and domestic violence, rendering the LGBTQ+ portrayal as not applicable to the film's content.
The film "Broken Blossoms or The Yellow Man and the Girl" does not feature any identifiable transsexual characters or themes. The narrative focuses on a tragic romance between a Chinese man and an abused English girl, exploring themes of racial prejudice and domestic violence, without any elements related to transgender identity.
The movie does not contain any action or adventure elements.
The film "Broken Blossoms" is an adaptation of a short story. A review of its main characters and their source material reveals no instances where a character's established gender was changed for the film's portrayal.
Viewer Rating Breakdown
User Ratings
7.2
6.9
Critic Ratings
9.5
N/A
More Like This
Leans Progressive
7.4
Priscilla
(2023)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Progressive
6.6
The History of Sound
(2025)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
6.6
Tortilla Soup
(2001)
Political: Center
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
7.7
Challengers
(2024)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
6.7
Romeo + Juliet
(1996)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
6.5
All of You
(2025)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Progressive
7.1
Desert Hearts
(1985)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
6.7
The Ballad of Little Jo
(1993)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Progressive
6.7
Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron
(2002)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
6.6
Carmen Jones
(1954)
Political: Center
Diversity: High
Progressive
7.4
Out
(2020)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
6.8
Ruth & Boaz
(2025)
Political: Leans Right
Diversity: High
Progressive
8.2
Brokeback Mountain
(2005)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Progressive
7.6
Children of a Lesser God
(1986)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
Progressive
7.3
Saturday Church
(2018)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: High
LGBTQ: Positive
Leans Progressive
9.7
Wall-E
(2008)
Political: Strong Left
Diversity: Moderate
Leans Progressive
6.7
I Love You Phillip Morris
(2010)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive
Progressive
7.5
Mississippi Masala
(1991)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: High
Leans Progressive
7.5
Carnal Knowledge
(1971)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
Leans Progressive
7.1
Frida
(2002)
Political: Leans Left
Diversity: Moderate
LGBTQ: Positive