The film "Father Figures" includes a gay character, Roland, who is portrayed positively as a successful, kind, and well-adjusted individual with a loving partner. His identity is integrated respectfully into the plot, and the narrative avoids making his sexuality a source of mockery or degradation, affirming the worth of his life and relationship.

Father Figures includes a transsexual character, Sarah, whose identity is revealed as a comedic twist. The humor derives from the main characters' shock and discomfort, reducing her identity to a punchline rather than exploring it with dignity or complexity. The portrayal lacks counterbalance or critique, contributing to a problematic depiction.

The film portrays a devout Christian character, Roland Hunt, who, despite being a source of comedic situations due to his earnestness, is ultimately depicted as a kind, loving, and sincere individual. His faith is presented as a genuine part of his character without being framed as hypocritical or problematic by the narrative.