The Good Fight consistently portrays LGBTQ+ characters with dignity, complexity, and agency. Relationships are depicted as normal, and identities are not sources of inherent conflict. The show often tackles LGBTQ+ rights issues through its legal cases, affirming the worth of queer lives and love.

The Good Fight features a storyline with Bianca, a trans woman, as a client fighting for her legal rights regarding frozen sperm. The portrayal is positive, depicting Bianca with dignity and agency. The narrative respectfully explores her identity and the external obstacles she faces, affirming the worth of trans lives and rights within a legal context.

The show frequently critiques the political and institutional manifestations of conservative Christianity, often highlighting hypocrisy, bigotry, or the misuse of faith to justify discriminatory practices. The narrative often positions these portrayals as problematic.

The show consistently portrays Islam and its adherents with sympathy, often highlighting the prejudice and Islamophobia they face in society. The narrative critiques bigotry against Islam, positioning the audience to empathize with Muslim characters.

Judaism is generally portrayed positively, integrated respectfully into the show's diverse cast of characters and cultural references. The narrative does not critique the faith itself.